This post contains affiliate links. Please see our disclosure policy.
My dad’s viral Caesar Dressing recipe has to be one of my top 5 favourite family recipes. It’s truly the best dressing I’ve ever had, and I’ve tried A LOT! Pretty much every restaurant I go to I’ll order the side Caesar; and while I’ve had many delicious versions, nothing compares to this one. It’s rich, creamy, garlicky, zesty, salty; all the things you’d want in a good Caesar Dressing This is a tried and true recipe that my family has been making for upwards of 20 years, so rest-assured you’ll love it!
Let’s stay connected
Keep in touch with me on Instagram, TikTok, and Pinterest! Also, if you do make this recipe (or any recipe of mine for that matter) be sure to tag #sammymontgoms so I can see your re-creations!
Ingredients
Here is a quick overview of the ingredients you’ll need to make Johnny B’s Caesar Dressing. For the exact detailed measurements and ingredients, scroll to the bottom of this page to review my recipe card.
- mayonnaise
- yellow mustard
- anchovy paste
- worcestershire
- garlic cloves
- lemon
- parmigiano-reggiano
- black pepper
Tips before getting started
- Use anchovy paste, rather than whole anchovies. It makes it much easier and the flavour is 10/10.
- Be sure to use a high quality imported parmigiano-reggiano from Italy. The cheese makes all the difference in this recipe, and the other kinds won’t taste as good.
- I use 4 large garlic cloves because I loooove me some garlic, but feel free to scale down the garlic and use 2 large cloves if you aren’t the biggest fan. It still tastes great, but isn’t too overpowering.
Storing instructions
Keep this one in your fridge in an airtight container for up to 7 days
Watch the recipe video
Watch the recipe video on Instagram
Johnny B’s Caesar Dressing
Ingredients
- 1½ cups mayonnaise
- 1 tbsp yellow mustard
- 1 tbsp anchovy paste
- 1 tbsp + 1/4 tsp worcestershire
- 4 garlic cloves, minced
- 1/2 lemon, juiced
- 1 tsp lemon zest
- 1¼ cup parmigiano-reggiano, finely grated
- 1/4 tsp black pepper
Instructions
- Begin by grating the parmigiano-reggiano.Set aside until ready to use.
- Zest and juice the lemon.Set aside until ready to use.
- To a medium sized bowl whisk all of the ingredients together really well. About 1-2 minutes.
- Taste to adjust seasioning accordingly.
- Pour over chopped romaine lettuce and croutons, and toss to combine.
- Enjoy!
Nutrition information is automatically calculated, so should only be used as an approximation.
How long can this dressing be stored in the fridge?
Hi Tyra! Up to a week is fine!
11/10! We had a really similar dressing growing up but we lost the family recipe card. I subbed Dijon for Yellow mustard and halved the recipe overall. Can’t wait for Caesar salad again later this week.
Hi Deana – WOO! I love it! So glad you enjoyed the dressing and thank you for the review!
BEST CAESAR EVER! I’ll start be saying, I love Caesar salads. AND very picky about the dressing. I’m sorry but I have yet to find a store bought Caesar dressing that rivals homemade. This was so simple to make. Wonderful topped grilled shrimp or chicken. I could put this particular dressing on cardboard and it would be terrific. Soooo, so good!!!!!
Hi Page! Oh I LOVE IT! Thank you for this review, SO happy you made it, and loved it!
I made this tonight and it was absolutely delicious. Its the only ceasar dressing I’m making from now on👌
Want to make this today and don’t have yellow mustard. I only have brown spicy mustard and Dijon mustard.
Will any of those work?
Sub for dijon mustard and it will be so good!
Can you substitute anchovy??
I would add a few tbsp of capers if you can’t use anchovy!
Made this today, in fridge right now melding until dinner. Hoping it’s as good as described by all the reviews. Only thing I’m not sure of is the yellow mustard. Turned it yellow never had yellow Caesar dressing before. Fingers crossed.
I ❤️ a good Caesar dressing, however anchovy can be overwhelming to me. Does using anchovy paste reduce the intensity of the anchovy’s? I can’t wait to try this though…. Thank you!
Hi Cristin, if you can’t use anchovy, you could ask add a few tablespoons of capers and blend it all really well. This will give it a more subtle flavour. You could also reduce the amount of anchovy paste you add. Hope this helps.
Made this spontaneously and it was the best. I had all the ingredients in the fridge except for anchovy paste. It was delicious and very easy.
Hi Joanne, thank you for taking the time to leave a review! So happy you enjoyed it!!
This dressing is absolutely BEYOND YUM!!! Never buying it again!! So easy to make also! Thank you for this, Sammy!!!!
Hi Vanessa! Thank you for taking the time to leave a review! So happy you love it!!
Your salad dressing has been a huge hit at my family gatherings! Thank you for sharing it.
Your salad dressing has been a huge hit at my family gatherings. Thank you for sharing!
Hi Melissa, that is SO awesome to hear. I am so happy you all enjoyed it!
Love all your recipes and this doesn’t disappoint!
Hi Jess! Thank you SO much!
It’s 🔥! And comes together in a 🫰. So creamy and delicious. Each day it keeps getting better. Make it! You won’t be disappointed.
LOVE THIS COMMENT and couldn’t agree more! Thanks Linda! xo
This was amazing- finally a Caesar dressing that I will stick with. I’ve tried so many on the Internet. I was apprehensive about the 1 Tbsp of anchovy paste but def the right amount. I made mine with homemade mayo too which takes 1 min to make and was well worth it!
Hi Paulina – SOOOO happy that you liked this recipe! Makes me so happy! Thanks for the review!
I am always concerned when measuring cheese, especially Parmesan. Are you using 4 oz or measuring out 1 cup? I’m dying to try this recipe but don’t want to overdo the cheese. Thanks!
Hi Roz, I use 1 cup + 1/4 of cheese! It’s a larger batch and needs more than you probably think! Hope this helps!
Curious if you’ve tried this with Greek yogurt versus mayo…I have folks with egg allergies in the building 🫣?
I haven’t personally tried it with greek yogurt, but some of my audience has, and they said they enjoyed it still! Hope that helps.
I JUST finished mixing this up and couldn’t wait for lunch to take a taste. AMAZING. My 11 year old agrees and she’s picky (definitely wouldn’t enjoy knowing about the anchovy paste, I have no problem with that being my secret). So delicious. I’m half tempted to have a salad for breakfast. Thank you for sharing. This will be a family favorite for a long time. I’m actually tossing the bottled dressing we already have on hand.
I am excited to try this but I am allergic to mustard – any suggestions for substitutes? Thanks!!
Just leave it out!
Made so many of your recipes and they were all delicious! Made this dressing for chicken Ceaser salad today and it’s amazing! Thank you Sammy!
Hi Catherine! Aw this is so awesome, thanks for being here, and taking the time to leave a review! xo, Sammy
Wow. Just the recipe I’ve been looking for all my life. This is the best caesar salad dressing recipe, ever. I’m so happy!
OMG!! The BEST caesar dressing. Just made a double batch bc the single batch didn’t last long. I could seriously sit and eat this with bread. Mahalo for sharing 😀
Hi Lauren! Thank you for taking the time to leave a review. I am so happy you enjoyed the recipe!!! xo -Sammy
Oh. My. Deliciousness… I just made this and have almost eaten an entire romaine just dipping it in! Addictive
Hi Stacy! I do the same thing. Thanks for leaving a review, and I am so happy you enjoy it! – Sammy
Just made this–I used dijon mustard instead of yellow mustard and it was delish. One of the best Caesar dressings I have had.
Hi Maureen! This is so awesome! Happy you loved the recipe!
Can you substitute out the anchovy paste??
You can take it out all together if you want, or you can add a tbsp or two of capers and then blend 🙂
Definitely keeping this one in my tried-and-tested file. Very delicious; the Caesar salad was absolutely smashed in minutes!! A Japanese student staying with us just about licked the plate!!